Understanding Self-Defense Charges

Being charged with assault or a violent crime in New York does not always mean you committed a crime. Under Penal Law Article 35, you may have acted lawfully in self-defense. If you reasonably believed you needed to protect yourself or another person from harm, your actions may be legally justified.

Even though self-defense is a complete legal justification, law enforcement often makes arrests based on who was injured—not on who started the conflict. This can leave you facing serious charges when you were simply protecting yourself or someone else.

At McCabe, Coleman, Ventosa & Patterson, we’ve defended countless clients across Dutchess, Ulster, Orange, Columbia, Greene, and Putnam counties who acted in self-defense. As former public defenders, we know how to raise justification effectively, challenge the prosecution’s evidence, and fight to ensure your side of the story is heard.

Standard vs. Self-Defense Outcomes in New York

When charged with assault or a violent offense, the consequences can be severe—but a valid self-defense claim may change everything.

Penalty / Outcome Standard Assault Conviction Assault with Successful Self-Defense Claim
Criminal Record Permanent criminal record No conviction if justified
Jail / Probation Possible jail time, probation, fines Case dismissed or charges reduced
Court-Mandated Programs Anger management, counseling, monitoring Not required
Loss of Rights Restrictions on employment, housing, firearms Rights preserved if charges dismissed
Long-Term Impact Ongoing stigma, barriers to future opportunities Freedom to move forward

Additional Potential Consequences

Without raising self-defense, you may also face:

  • Up to 3 years of probation
  • Up to 1 year in county jail (even as a first-time offender)

With a strong legal defense asserting justification, many clients avoid these penalties entirely.

Common Questions About Self-Defense Charges

Jail is possible in assault cases—but if you acted in self-defense, you may avoid conviction altogether. With experienced legal representation, many clients are able to get charges dismissed or reduced when justification is properly raised.

A conviction for assault can impact your employment, housing, and even your right to own firearms. But if your actions are found to be legally justified, you will not face these long-term consequences.

Criminal charges are a matter of public record, but the outcome of your case matters. A dismissal or acquittal based on self-defense protects your reputation and future.

Every case is different. Some are resolved quickly if justification is clear, while others may take months and require a trial. Your attorney’s strategy plays a major role in the timeline.

Contact an experienced criminal defense lawyer immediately. Do not speak to police or prosecutors without counsel. Preserve any evidence—texts, videos, witness names—that supports your claim of self-defense.

Why Choose Us for Your Self-Defense Case?

Thousands of Cases Handled

We’ve defended countless clients facing assault and violent crime charges throughout the Hudson Valley.

Former Public Defenders

All of our attorneys are former public defenders with extensive courtroom experience and a strong record of raising justification defenses.

Local Knowledge

We know the judges, prosecutors, and courts across Dutchess, Ulster, Orange, Columbia, Greene, and Putnam counties—and how they approach self-defense cases.

Proven Results

We regularly secure dismissals, reductions, and favorable outcomes by successfully asserting self-defense.

Discreet Representation

We’ve represented professionals, parents, students, and first-time defendants with compassion, skill, and discretion.

Reviews for Assault (Self-Defense)

Melinda Sefcik

from Google Reviews

I recently had the pleasure of working with McCabe, Coleman, Ventosa & Patterson PLLC. I am profoundly grateful that our paths crossed. They provided excellent support and guidance during an emotional time for me and my family. John and the firm’s commitment to excellence and relentless pursuit of justice made such a meaningful impact on my case. I truly appreciated the advocacy, dedication, and professionalism shown throughout the entire process. The administrative staff was equally impressive, handling everything efficiently and with a warm, respectful demeanor. From start to finish, the entire team made me feel valued. If you’re looking for a firm that combines professionalism with outstanding results, this is the one to choose!

Michael Coffey

from Google Reviews

Steven Patterson Esq. went above and beyond for me, treating me like a client/friend every step of the way through my FREE consultation. He provided me with essential legal advice and expecting nothing in return—I can only imagine how dedicated/enthusiastic he would be if I was a paying client. He is a brilliant attorney and I know I would have been in good hands if I needed legal representation. McCabe, Coleman, Ventosa & Patterson PLLC has a proven track record of success and I highly recommend their firm to anyone in need of legal services!!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

Exceptional service and expertise throughout every interaction! Highly recommend John and his team.

From start to finish, John and his team were an absolute pleasure to work with. John took the time to thoroughly get to know my wife and I and our needs. He was extremely prompt in answering all of our questions, and even answered questions we didn’t know we had. We never had to ask for follow up, because John always beat us to it. His knowledge of business law helped us to skillfully navigate a difficult situation. We are happy to say we will be using John and his team as both our family and business attorney for all of our future needs.

I have worked with both John Ventosa and Chris Coleman on both simple and complex legal matters. John, Chris and the entire staff have been thorough and professional every step of the way. I recommend this firm to anyone seeking sound and honest legal representation.

John ventosa was very patient and helpful for what I needed. Will definitely use their services again.

I don’t know where to start. Mr.Ventosa is a person who saved my life as a young adult and gave me a second chance in life. Watching him for 2 years take on my case and fight for me like he was my own family showed me his passion and character as a man. Case after case he showed up and was consistent with the 2 cases I caught as a young adult and he told me to not give up things will be better in the end. His words were so encouraging I became accountable as a man to do better and understand the choices I made were immature. He is the reason why I am back focused on the journey I began with during college and his tough characteristics gave me a sign to be mature in a time where I am entering my adulthood. Words can’t express how I feel about him and if you do come across a situation and you need a second chance in life please contact him I promise you he WILL
NOT LET YOU DOWN. THANK YOU MR.VENTOSA YOU ARE TRULY APPRECIATED FOR YOUR HARD WORK AND CONSISTENCY !!

Christopher Coleman is an honorable figure and exceptional attorney. In a world filled with greedy and unethical people, and just down right bad actors – Mr. Coleman is a light at the end of a tunnel and a fighter. He will tell you upfront what to expect and how he sees your situation turning out. He won’t waste your time or your money, or have you going down a rabbit hole, like other attorneys build their practices around. He’s the attorney you want defending you and negotiating for you. But he’s also the same attorney that you should use in bettering yourself and avoiding future problems in business and life. If you need an attorney, you can breathe a little better at night knowing you’re in good hands.

John Ventosa Is such an incredible lawyer. He is the most compassionate, kind and understanding Lawyer I have met. He is the best at what he does and takes such good care of his clients. John and his whole team is very helpful in walking your through every process and takes the time to answer all of your questions and concerns. If you are in the need of a fantastic lawyer look no further than John Ventosa.

John Ventosa is absolutely amazing to work with. He helped my husband and I through a very difficult time on a Saturday of all days!! He was patient, detailed, transparent and communicated updates every step of the way. We truly appreciate him and highly recommend him!!!

Let's Put This Behind You

An self-defense charges in New York can feel like a devastating setback—but it doesn’t have to define your future. At McCabe, Coleman, Ventosa & Patterson, we understand what’s at stake, and we know how to fight for your rights, your record, and your reputation.

Experienced Representation

With over 200 years of combined experience, our attorneys ensure you have strong, informed advocates on your side.

Personalized Guidance

We take the time to understand your unique situation, offering clear advice and dedicated support throughout the process.

Local & Accessible

With deep roots in the community, we are committed to providing trusted legal representation right where you live and work.
Schedule Your Appointment Today

Request a Consultation